Check our newest product: Freeze Dried Bone Broth!

Free delivery for orders over $125!

Maple-Glazed Christmas Turkey Recipe

written by

Bethany Fisher

posted on

December 13, 2024

Christmas-Turkey.png

Christmas is in the air! Trees are going up, Christmas lights enchant people’s homes, carols spread the Christmas cheer…all of which means it’s the time of year to begin planning your Christmas gathering with family and friends!

My family’s home (Bethany here!) was the gathering place for our family Christmases. I love cooking, especially for large groups of people. I love how food brings everyone together, and seeing all the smiles and hearing the laughter around the table as we enjoy a good meal is the best part.

The star protein of our family’s Christmas meals vary from year to year, but the maple orange glaze is always a constant. So this year, I wanted to share with you a recipe for the tastiest Christmas turkey ever! Sweet meets savory in this take on a Christmas turkey. Maple glaze with bright notes of citrus…a gravy with Whiffletree seasoning meat and thyme…what’s not to love?

Grab your pasture-raised Whiffletree turkey HERE and give this recipe a try!

What you’ll need:

For your turkey:

1 whole pasture-raised turkey, thawed and giblets removed (brined or not brined! I did just a simple 24 hour saltwater brine for my turkey)

4 oranges

Handful of thyme sprigs

6 cloves garlic, peeled and crushed

½ tsp whole allspice

For your maple butter glaze:

¾ c. unsalted butter

1 c. maple syrup

½ tsp whole cloves

For your gravy:

1 package Whiffletree seasoning meat (similar flavor to bacon! You can use bacon, but I used seasoning meat in this recipe because it’s fattier and I wanted the fats for the gravy)

2 cloves garlic, minced

1 ½ tsp thyme leaves

⅓ c. flour

3 c. reserved drippings and broth (you’ll make this from the turkey neck and giblets)

Salt and pepper to taste

Optional garnish:

Pomegranate seeds (adds a nice contrasting color and a pop of flavor!)

How to Prepare:

Preheat your oven to 325F.

First, make your maple butter glaze. Melt ¾ cup butter over low heat. Add the maple syrup, the juice from two of your oranges, and the cloves. Bring to a simmer and let cook for a few minutes before removing from the heat. 

Remove your turkey from the package, take off the plastic truss, and set into a roasting pan. Make sure to take the giblets out of the cavity and save them for your gravy! Now is also the time to remove the turkey neck if you wish.

Next, cut the 4 remaining oranges into halves and place in the cavity of the turkey, along with 6 cloves of garlic, ½ tsp whole allspice, and a small handful of thyme (make sure to save enough thyme to get about 1 tsp of thyme leaves from). Then, if desired, take some kitchen twine and truss the legs together. Now take your maple butter glaze and spread all over the turkey skin with a pastry brush. (Make sure to leave about a cup for serving later with your turkey!) Then place the turkey into your heated oven.

*Note: The rule of thumb is 8-10 minutes per pound of turkey, but always plan for less so you don’t overcook your turkey. If you have one, place an oven-safe thermometer into the breast before putting it into the oven. You want the meat to reach 165F to be safe for eating, but no more as you don’t want dry turkey! The breast tends to cook faster than the leg, so if it reaches 165F but the leg doesn’t read that temp yet, simply cut off the legs and leave in the oven to keep roasting until done. This way you don’t overcook any part of your turkey!

While the turkey is roasting, you can start prepping your gravy! Put your reserved giblets (and turkey neck if you removed it) into a small pot and cover with 4.5 cups of water. Set over medium low heat and bring to a simmer. Simmer for 30 minutes. Remove from heat, take out the giblets and turkey neck, and set them aside to cool, saving the broth in the pot. After the giblets have cooled, finely dice them.

After the turkey has reached 165F, drain off the drippings into a bowl and set the turkey aside somewhere to keep warm while you prep the gravy.

Next, fry up your Whiffletree seasoning meat in a medium saucepan over medium heat. Once the meat is fully cooked, remove to a plate, leaving all the fats behind in the pan. Turn the heat to medium low. Mince your remaining two cloves of garlic and add to the fat, along with 1 tsp. thyme leaves stripped from the stalks. Cook until the garlic is starting to brown and is fragrant. Then, add in the flour, whisking to make a roux. Let the roux cook for a few minutes while stirring often to keep it from burning. Next, slowly pour in 3 cups of your reserved drippings and your giblet broth, whisking the entire time to keep clumps from forming. Cook the gravy for a few minutes or until it reaches your desired thickness. Once it reaches the right consistency, remove from heat, add the diced giblets, and stir in salt and pepper to taste.

And you’re all set! Carve up your turkey and serve with the seasoning meat, thyme gravy, maple butter glaze, and optional pomegranate. Enjoy!

More from the blog

Busy Mom's Tip #1: How to Feed Quality Food to Your Family on a Budget

Food is medicine. And as a mom (or dad), you want to be able to give your kids the absolute best you can so they have a healthy foundation to thrive on… But how? How do you feed your kids good quality, local, pasture-raised food when you’re on a budget? How do you find the time to do everything you need to do PLUS prepare healthy foods from scratch? How do you find the time to learn how to cook and prepare foods you’ve never had to before? Liz Straight has some helpful, down-to-earth tips she has implemented into her life as a homeschool mom of eight kids. She knows firsthand the difficulties of finding time and budgeting to be able to feed her family nourishing food without running herself into the ground. Over the next few weeks, we’ll be sharing Liz’s tips with you to help you on this journey of healthy eating. The great thing about these tips is that they apply to everyone - whether you’re a dad, a mom, or a single person working full time. They’re practical. This week, Liz shares her first tip… Tip # 1: Budget around cost effective cuts and foods. Meal plan around your meat. Look for the cuts or products that you can afford and build meal plans and budget around that (more on meal planning in another tip!). When choosing the most budget-friendly cuts, don’t go for convenience as you will end up paying for the labor of processing to make that cut convenient. Whole chickens versus parts is a great example of that. Look for larger cuts of meat, such as roasts or whole chickens. They actually don’t take a lot of time to prepare and are much easier on your wallet.Don’t throw away scraps! Save all your bones for stock.  It is ok to make a mix-and-match "mutt" stock in your crockpot with any kinds of bones.  It is amazing how having stock on hand can make a meal.  You can easily make a "refrigerator soup" with leftover bits of meat and veggies and herbs if you have broth around all the time.  Great if someone gets sick or you didn't have a chance to thaw new meat for dinner.   Make some easy muffins to go with it and that's dinner! Fats are also great to keep - that fat from the bacon you fried this morning is great for cooking eggs, tossing with popcorn, etc. Fats also help to make meals more filling, helping stretch food further.And always check for what’s on sale or buy bulk packs of eggs or meat! An extra freezer is really handy for this so that when something does go on sale or you purchase that bulk pack of meat, you have extra room to stock up. You can check out Whiffletree’s sale and bulk items HERE.And if you have the extra space for a big chest freezer, buying a whole/half/quarter cow or pig is a great way to buy in bulk while getting the maximum savings you can.When it comes to veggies and fruits, buy fruit that is cheaper and longer lasting the majority of the time, such as apples, oranges, carrots, etc. There is less waste and kids enjoy some of the sweet things but are less likely to gobble it all down the minute it comes home. Then more expensive and shorter lasting things like berries, melons, or grapes are super special as a treat to them. And again, don’t go for convenience. Pre-cut veggies are more expensive and often don’t last as long so it’s harder to buy in bulk. (Something like a food processor can help you budget your time more effectively when you use whole veggies - whiz away!)Looking into a raw milk share can help save a little money on proteins - it’s a set price so it makes it easy to budget and the milk FILLS you. It makes a great snack or addition to a meal that’s not quite as filling. Plus raw milk is full of so many health benefits.All this doesn’t mean you can’t indulge in a ribeye or filet steak once in a while, but if money is tight keep those types of cuts to a minimum. Focus on buying other foods that are filling but still nutrient dense and tasty. And that’s the first tip! Next week, we’ll take a look at what meal planning for a family of ten looks like for Liz!Make sure to check out sale and bulk items HERE!

Budget Series: How to Make Healing Bone Broth

If you’re a mama wanting to make sure your kids get the best they can to give them a healthy foundation for living life… Or an individual looking to boost your overall health… Or someone who suffers from health issues and is looking for something to give your body a break and a chance to heal… Then this is the post for you! Pasture-raised chicken (or any meat) that is fed a diet free from chemicals and preservatives, that can forage for added nutrition from bugs and grass, that has continual access to clean living spaces, water, sunlight, and fresh air - all this will produce a bird that is much higher in all the nutrients you want your bone broth to be rich in. It will also have a balanced omega 3-6 ratio, so the fats will actually be healthy and beneficial rather than detrimental. As the last part of our budget series on cooking whole chickens, I’ll walk you through how to make a healing bone broth out of the nutrient-dense bones, joints, and skin you are left with after cooking a whole chicken. It’s an absolute powerhouse of nutrition! The bones contain trace minerals, and the skin and joints are rich in collagen, amino acids, protein, etc.! And the best part is you can make this healing broth with almost no effort from yourself! Just stick it in a crockpot or stock pot on the stove and let the magic begin. How to Make Healing Bone Broth: Ingredients: 1 chicken carcass or 2 chicken backs (if you are making broth from bones you save after cooking a whole chicken, make sure you save EVERYTHING - the skin, joints, cartilage, and bones!) Enough water to cover the bones by about an inch 1 tsp salt (optional) Herbs, veggies, or garlic (optional) Directions: Place your chicken carcass in the crockpot or stock pot, then cover with water so there’s about an inch of water above the bones (some will simmer off as it cooks). Then add in any salt, herbs, veggies, or garlic to add some flavor. If using a crockpot, turn the settings to low. If you are using a stock pot, bring to a simmer and then turn the burner to low. Then let it cook for at least 16 hours. To get all the healing benefits, it takes at least that much time for the bones and cartilage to break down and release their nutrients into the broth. If you can, go longer and cook it for 24 hours. After 16-20 hours, strain into a jar. Don’t skim off the fat that rises to the top - that fat is full of health benefits and will coat your digestive track, soothing it. And there you have it! You have one of the most nutrient dense foods right at your fingertips with very little time invested from you. I love just adding a little salt and drinking the broth as it is, or using it as a base for sauces and soups. As someone who has digestive and joint issues, I can attest to the benefits that bone broth provides. More energy, healthier skin, less joint pain, a soothed tummy, and the list goes on. Next up on the blog, we’ll be doing a series of tips and tricks from Liz Straight on budgeting time and money to feed a family of ten using pasture-raised food. Stay tuned! Cheers! Bethany